THE BOY DETECTIVE FAILS
By JOE MENO

Akashic Books/Punk Planet, 2006
ISBN 1933354100
328 pages; Paperback
GENRE(S): Fiction, Mystery

Reviewed by Bri Lafond

What would happen to your favorite children's book stars if they could grow up? Would Nancy Drew be working in the Special Victims Unit, perkily assisting victims identify their rapists? Would the Hardy Boys have their own P.I. firm, snapping tele-lens photos of pudgy middle aged guys in flagrante delicto with their secretaries? Would Encyclopedia Brown ever get laid? Joe Meno takes on the character of the child detective all grown up—in the form of one Billy Argo—in his latest offering, The Boy Detective Fails.
ADVERTISEMENT

Billy Argo reached the peak of his career in his teens. Since then, it's all been downhill. He's spent the last ten years in a mental hospital after the disappearance of his sister and partner in detection, Caroline. Plagued by visions of disappearing buildings (something not so unbelievable in this post-9/11 world) and his old—and now senile—nemesis, Professor von Golum, Billy tries to get his life back in order by moving into a halfway house and getting his first non-detecting job. But Billy is haunted by the unsolved disappearance of Caroline and he falls back on his detection skills to figure out what happened to his sister ten years ago.

The Boy Detective Fails is an amazing book. Meno takes on the conventions of the child detective novel and twists them into an enthralling read. The mood is pitch-perfect with the wonder of childhood and the pessimism of adulthood crashing together in a metaphysical vision that comments on both the constraints of genre fiction and the realities of contemporary life; the clichéd narrative arcs that define Billy's childhood clash with the randomness of modern existence. These ideas are further underlined by the book's form, which is chock-full of hidden codes and even a decoder ring that the reader has to put together, meshing the adult and youth reading experiences into a wholly unique reading experience.

Mysterious and charming, The Boy Detective Fails is a surefire hit for those who grew up on Nancy Drew and Encyclopedia Brown. Moreover, it's a great book in general that will appeal to any fan of literary fiction.

(November, 2007)

 

 
     

© 2007 hipsterbookclub.com
All Rights Reserved