WAS SUPERMAN A SPY?
By BRIAN CRONIN

Plume, 2009
ISBN: 9780452295322
256 pages; Paperback
GENRE(S): Nonfiction, History

Reviewed by Kyle Olson

Trivia is largely the purview of nerds. Often, after it's discovered that social skills, sports, and a healthy grasp of what's "cool" have eluded them, a nerd will turn inward, focusing on the realm in which they excel: learning. As trivia is learning for learning's sake, it could be argued that it is the purest of the nerd arts, honed and brandished at comic-cons and internet message boards across the land. And when the subject of said trivia is comic books, one experiences a singularity of pure nerdgasm that can alter the very fabric of space-time. Somewhere at the center of that vortex is a copy of Was Superman a Spy?: 256 pages of pure, unadulterated, black tar comic trivia.

Brian Cronin, author of the blog Comics Should Be Good, writes a regular feature called "Comic Book Legends Revealed" in which he explores popular tales of comic book lore, exposing them as fact or fiction. Was Superman a Spy? collects many of his favorites from the blog, as well as several dozen new legends, into one handy volume. Want to know which comic book almost got a guest appearance by Jesus Christ? Care to know how Donald Duck and ping pong balls fit into Swedish patent law? Any guesses how many comic book companies Alan Moore has a blood feud with? (Answer: damned near all of them.) While some of these pieces of trivia will be familiar to those with even a casual interest in comics, this book offers a good deal of new information to titillate one's yen for pop culture minutiae.

The book is divided up into sections on DC, Marvel, and other comic companies, with each company getting further subdivisions focusing on specific (higher profile) characters such as Batman or the X-Men. While having 28 straight pages of Batman trivia sounds like it could become dry or tedious, Cronin's conversational writing makes the subject readable. It's not the finest prose in the world, but bear in mind this book was born in a blog. Besides, if 28 pages of Batman trivia doesn't sound like your cup of tea, it's shocking you've made it this far in the review.

Seemingly unintentionally, Was Superman a Spy? gives readers a tremendous back story on the history of comic books, as well as pop culture and U.S. history in general. Stories relating to the Comics Code Authority and the first African-American characters depict times in America's history rife with witch hunts, censorship, and the effects of the civil rights movement on other mediums. Simply by virtue of these tales, Cronin provides the reader with a triangulation on American history. Captain America fights Hitler, then the "commies." The stories contained are diverse enough to span from comic books' inception pre-World War 2 all the way through modern day film adaptations, making this book an excellent primer on the entire subject.

Was Superman a Spy?—for being blog-caliber writing, centering on a niche topic, and featuring infinitely more stories on comic book litigation than anyone thought possible—is a light, fairly entertaining, and informative read. This book promises little-known stories about comic book history, and it infuses these stories with enthusiasm and fun. It's doubtful that even the most dyed-in-the-Wolverine-T-Shirt comics nerd was previously aware of all of Cronin's tales, making this a safe bet for socially awkward fact-collectors everywhere.

(June, 2009)

 

ADVERTISEMENT

 
     

© 2007 hipsterbookclub.com
All Rights Reserved