|
Memoir-writing,
especially about tragic events that turn out positively, can
affect readers in highly emotional waysI remember how
people really fell in love with James Frey, and how everybody
was amazed by the events in The Glass Castle. What
sort of feedback have you gotten from the public about Gilrbomb
and Have You Found Her?
I got great feedback about Girlbomb, and so far the
response to Have You Found Her has been really good,
too. Ninety-five percent of that feedback comes from women
who have found themselves in similar circumstances to mine,
whether they were wild girls in high school, or wide-eyed
volunteers in their thirties. I hear from a lot of ex-homeless
women, or women who have had insane co-dependent relationships
with girls they mentored. I bet Jeannette Walls gets a shitload
of email from formerly poor people. I'm grateful for every
e-mail or blog comment I receive. Nobody has expressed any
skepticism over any of the events portrayed in either book,
as extreme as some of those events were, because, unfortunately,
so many other people have lived through similar things.
I
think the public accepts and loves memoirs, but some book
critics seem a little snippy about them. Any thoughts on that?
Is it just an old-guard reaction to a zeitgeist change?
Memoirists are the reality show contestants of the literary
world. We're shameless, navel-gazing attention whores, and
we're degrading the culture with our whining and self-pity.
Readers don't mind because they're just looking for a good
story that will help shed some light on their own lives, but
critics are really annoyed by us, probably because there are
so damn many of us, and we're all competing to see who had
it worst.
I
think after the Frey fiasco, some readers and critics began
to conflate memoirs with journalistic writing, which it clearly
is not. What's your opinion regarding the subjective truths
offered in memoirs?
My opinion is this: Don't lie. Tell the truth as you remember
it. Be as honest as you can be. But don't worry about being
journalistically correct about everything. A memoir is more
about feelings than about facts; it's an emotional journey,
not a logistical one. If you want to write a history of your
family, then do the research and write one. But if you just
want to write your own story, fuck the research, and write
what you remember. That's what's important to readers.
After
reading Girlbomb, Have You Found Her seemed
almost like a sequel. Much of Girlbomb centers on your
difficult relationship with your mother, and in Have You
Found Her it seems like you were trying to mend that by
mentoring a homeless girl who reminded you of yourself as
a teenager.
Totally. I definitely think of the second book as a sequel
to the firstit's the exact same setting and main character,
with most of the same problems, just 19 years later. I was
indeed trying to mother someone to make up for my own lack
of mothering, and I got so involved in repairing my own shit
that I didn't see the young person who was right in front
of me…until it was too late.
You
were finishing up Girlbomb while the events of Have
You Found Her were transpiring. Did your relationship
with Samantha help to illuminate anything that you had been
going through when you were a homeless teenager? How much
of that affected Girlbombwere you able to incorporate
that any of that into the book?
I'd actually just finished Girlbomb when I met SamI
think I handed in the book the week before we met. I remember
meeting with my original editor in January of 2005 to discuss
the minor edits she wanted to make, and being completely distracted
during the meeting because I was worried about my new friend
Sam, who'd just been remanded to a psych ward. So Samantha
didn't shed any light on things when I was writing the book,
but the girls I met at the shelter before her did. I paid
close attention to their emotional states, their ways of interacting
with each other, and especially their dialogue. Some of the
dialogue in Girlbomb was directly lifted from conversations
I heard between them.
It's
kind of hard to talk about Have You Found Her without
giving away too much, which I don't want to do since it has
such an emotional impact. Did you find it difficult yourself
to maintain the distance needed while writing so that you
didn't telegraph what happens?
Yeah,
there's kind of a surprise ending to the book, which I didn't
see coming when I was living it. And then the book was due
so soon after the events had unfoldedI didn't have a
lot of time to live with the strong feelings they inspired
before I started writing about them. Which is one reason that
I tore through the first draft475 pages in three months.
I was dying to get it over with so I could stop fucking dwelling
in the most painful place imaginable. And I was a wreck while
writing it. I write in a shared workspace and often had to
stop and get up from my desk and go into the bathroom so that
other people didn't see me cry or turn purple with rage. At
one point, I really thought I was going to have an aneurism.
So I really had no emotional distance at all for the first
draft, which is why it took eight more months and two more
drafts to get it to a place where it was publishable.
Sam
was lucky to have found three smart, resourceful women who
were willing to help her find housing and get into rehab.
Was her experience unusual, or do many of shelter teens form
these sorts of relationships?
I think Sam was unusually charismatic and bright, and she'd
learned to draw people in to her story, so she was able to
get a lot more help and a greater share of the available resources
than other residents did. But I know other volunteers and
social workers who have made very strong personal commitments
to particular kids, so I know that it happensjust not
for everyone, which is a shame. Every young person in crisis
needs as many advocates and allies as they can get, not just
the smart, funny ones.
When
did you decide to write about what happened between you and
Sam? And how much changed about your approach during the course
of writing the book?
After Girlbomb, I was working on a novel, which my
original editor had approved, but then she abruptly changed
her mind and told me to start over with a new idea, not that
I had one. Fortunately, by then, it was becoming obvious that
the most salient thing in my life was my volunteering, and
specifically my relationship with Sam, so I knew the next
book would be about that. There are some posts on my blog
from Summer 2005 where I'm trying to figure out how to write
about Sam and the other girls from the shelter without exploiting
them or invading their privacy. Sam had given me explicit
permission to write about her (using the name "Sam," and not
her real name), but I was still grappling with the exploitation/privacy
issue when the plot twist hit us. Then I realized, "Well,
fuck everything else, I've got to write about this
now."
But as much as the plot changed over the course of the planning
of this book, my approach to the writing of it was consistentI
went back and looked at my journals, emails, and blog posts,
and tried to write as honestly and accurately as I could about
the events, sparing myself nothing along the way. That's my
"process," and it didn't change.
What
about your next book? Do you think you'll stick with memoir?
I personally might like to read a book about your slam poetry
days when you toured with Lollapalooza.
Right now, I'm working on more memoirs, though I may decide
to turn it into fiction, despite everything I said above about
owning your shit. I owned my shit for two books; I might try
to give myself a break for the third one. But there isn't
that much more of my past left to mine for material, and I'm
hoping that nothing insane enough to be worth writing about
ever happens to me again.
(April,
2008)
|