|
AN INTERVIEW
WITH JANICE ERLBAUM
By
MARIE MUNDACA
Though
she's only in her mid-30s, Janice Erlbaum has already
published two acclaimed memoirs. In Girlbomb: A Halfway
Homeless Memoir, Erlbaum writes about her years
as a homeless teenager in New York City during the 1980s.
In her new book, Have You Found Her, Erlbaum
goes back to the shelter that helped her stay safe,
and she forms a deep relationship with a highly intelligent,
drug-addicted girl named Samantha. What begins as a
caring mentoring relationship quickly devolves into
clingy codependency as this bright, promising young
woman is diagnosed with HIV. Janice spoke with the Hipster
Book Club about the process of memoir writing, truth
and lies, and convincing The New York Times that
you're for real.
|
You
started writing Girlbomb: A Halfway Homeless Memoir
prior to the James Frey thing happening. How far along were
you when his duplicity was discovered, and did that cause
you to reevaluate anything you were doing?
Girlbomb was finished, edited, printed, and only eight
weeks away from release when James Frey was exposed by The
Smoking Gun as having made up a whole bunch of shit in his
two "memoirs." I read the story as it broke that Sunday night
in January of 2006, and the first thing I did was crap my
pants (metaphorically), because I knew this was one of the
worst possible things that could happen right before my book
releasenow all memoirists were going to be seen as liars,
and I'd be releasing the book into a hostile climate.
The
second thing I did was to write to my editor and the lawyer
who'd vetted my book during the editing phase, to say, "Hey,
let me come in with all my archivesmy notes and datebooks
and report cards and et cetera from high schooland reassure
you guys that I'm for reals." They graciously allowed this,
so I lugged a giant box of yellowing old paper up to the lawyer's
office and went through it with them, item by item"See?
I really was a slutty little drug addict! I really
did steal money from my afterschool job! I promise!"
It was a bizarre experience, trying to convince people that
I was an unsavory miscreant in my youth, rather than the opposite.
I remember talking to a guy from The New York Times
that week, and offering to show him how to fold a snow-seal
to carry your cocaine in, just to prove my street cred.
Why
did you decide to do Girlbomb, and then your new book
Have You Found Her, as memoir, as opposed to a fictionalized
account of these two highly personal events? Had you considered
writing Girlbomb as a novel at any point?
It never occurred to me to present either of these books as
anything other than the truth. I felt like the fact that they
were true stories made them way more interesting than fictionalized
versions could have been. Also, I don't think you gain anything
by writing your life story and then tweaking it and calling
it "fiction." You don't spare yourself or anyone else in your
life any of the embarrassment or pain, since readers automatically
assume that any main character is based on the author, and
your mom is going to recognize herself no matter what fictional
hair color you gave her. I've read some works of fiction that
were thinly veiled memoirs, and been like, "Why?" Just fucking
own your shit, you know?
Of course, I know that I'm a horrible solipsist, as all memoirists
are, and I'm not trying to take anything away from fiction
as a genreI love it. I just love it more when it's not
so obviously based on the writers' life, but with better skin
and a happier ending.
Memoir
writing, especially when it's not explicitly humorous, seems
like a pretty ballsy act. Were you afraid of the reactions
from certain people in the books when they came out, and how
founded or unfounded were your fears?
Ugh. You know, if anyone reading this is working on a memoir,
I suggest that you do your best to forget that anyone else
is ever going to read it. Because I was totally afraid of
people's reactions, and in many cases my fears were completely
founded. Some people were pretty sanguine about what I wrote
about them, but others were pissed. It is pretty ballsy to
write shit about other people, but I don't know if it's good-ballsy
or bad-ballsy, you know? It sucks, that you sometimes have
to invade people's privacy in order to tell your own story,
but as long as you stick to the truth, and make yourself look
as bad as you make others look, you should be able to sleep
at night knowing that you were honest and fair.
Both
your books offer quite a bit of introspection about the events
you've written about. Were any of those insights a surprise
to you?
Well, I've spent the past 12.5 years in therapy, so I'd already
done a lot of the hard work of figuring out why the hell I
was such a fuck-up for so long. But yeah, I had insights that
surprised me while writing, though most of them were insights
about other people. When writing Girlbomb, I realized
that I was the same age my mom was when the events of the
book started, and that threw me for a loophow would
I have acted, I had to ask myself, if I were in her shoes,
with an emotionally damaged young daughter and no support
system? That was a revelation to me. I also realized some
things about my girlfriends, like my "evil" ex-best-friend
Alice, whose mother was completely absent for most of our
adolescence. At the time, it was like, "Cool, Alice has it
so good, her mom's never home." Then while writing the book,
I realized, "God, that must have sucked for Alice, to have
had no parenting or stability whatsoever." But I was already
all too aware of all my own damage when I started writing
both books. It was other people's damage that surprised me.
Is
memoir writing emotionally draining, cathartic, or both?
Memoir writing sucks. It's so fucking painful and exhausting.
Reliving the worst parts of your life, the mistakes you've
regretted for years, the humiliations, the bad hairstyles,
the whole thing sucks. I thought I had leukemia when I was
writing Girlbomb, because I had to keep lying down
on the floor of my office and taking naps; I smoked a bushel
of marijuana while writing both books. But then when it's
done, it's the most cathartic thing in the world. It has left
your body, and it's outside of you now. I was carrying around
so much shit that I just don't have to hang on to anymore,
because it's right there in a book, in case I ever need it.
[continued
on page 2]
|